Friday, January 9, 2015

Supply and demand in action or price discrimination?

The Middle Seat. Airline Fare Riddle: One Route, Two Prices
by: Scott McCartney
Jan 08, 2015
Click here to view the full article on WSJ.com
Click here to view the video on WSJ.com WSJ Video

TOPICS: Price Discrimination, Supply and Demand
SUMMARY: Airlines charge different prices for the same round-trip ticket depending on where you start your trip, a study conducted for The Wall Street Journal shows.
CLASSROOM APPLICATION: Students can evaluate whether airlines setting different prices for the same round-trip ticket depending on the where flyers start their trips is an example of price discrimination. In some cases the price differences is an example of price discrimination: "Some cities have more buyers of last-minute tickets at higher prices, which drives up the average for tickets sold in one direction over another, a Delta spokesman said." In other cases, it is due to limited capacity and increased demand: "A United spokesman said holiday travel periods drive demand directionally, pushing fares higher."
QUESTIONS: 
1. (Advanced) Define third-degree (i.e., multi-market) price discrimination. Consider the case in which flights from New York to London and from London to New York are not full. Suppose the flight from New York to London is more expensive. Is this example of third-degree price discrimination?

2. (Advanced) Define second-degree price discrimination. Business travelers, who have a more price-inelastic demand, sometimes reserve flights at the last minute, while leisure travelers plan ahead. Is the case in which an airline raises the price of a flight as its date approaches an example of second-degree price discrimination?

3. (Introductory) Is the following case about travel between the mainland and Hawaii an example of price discrimination? A United spokesman said holiday travel periods drive demand directionally, pushing fares higher. "There may be fewer deeply discounted seats available on preholiday Hawaii-bound flights because of the increased demand by mainland travelers," he said.

Reviewed By: James Dearden, Lehigh University

Supply and demand in action in the long run

Food 'Accelerators' and the $10 Bag of Pasta
by: Erica E. Phillips
Jan 07, 2015
Click here to view the full article on WSJ.com

TOPICS: Entry into the food industry, Production
SUMMARY: As tastes shift toward specialty foods, more "food startups" are entering the market. Nearly $570 million in venture capital has been invested in such firms over the past five years, a financial database shows.
CLASSROOM APPLICATION: Students can evaluate three issues with regard to the specialty food industry. First, with an increase in demand for locally-sourced, organic food, specialty producers are entering the market. Second, there are entry costs, in particular the costs involved with passing public health inspections. The article reports that Los Angeles County, in particular, is setting appropriate, lower-cost health standards for small food producers. Third, the article notes the construction of a food production center, L.A. Prep, to house as many as 50 businesses. Presumably, the center will provide economies of scale.
QUESTIONS: 
1. (Introductory) What is the effect of the increased demand for locally-sourced, organic food on the prices of this type of food?

2. (Advanced) What is the effect of the increased demand for locally-sourced, organic food on entry into this segment of the food industry? What is the effect of entry into this segment on the prices of locally-sourced, organic food?

3. (Advanced) Will the producers of locally-sourced, organic food remain small?

Reviewed By: James Dearden, Lehigh University

Supply and demand in action

The Numbers. Why Gas Feels Cheap : and Why It's Not, Historically Speaking
by: Jo Craven McGinty
Jan 13, 2015
Click here to view the full article on WSJ.com

TOPICS: Consumption, Oil Markets, Supply and Demand
SUMMARY: The Numbers: Gas prices are now more than a dollar below the 2014 average, a level that is cheap relative to a recent run of record highs but not yet near the 17-year stretch from 1986-2003. The column reports not only on the historical prices of gasoline, but also on consumer responses to lower gasoline prices, the effect of lower prices on the U.S. economy, automobile purchases, and decisions about hydraulic fracturing. Related article: The downturn in energy prices has triggered debate over whether Texas simply got lucky in recent years or whether it hit on an economic playbook that other states could emulate.
CLASSROOM APPLICATION: Students can evaluate the consumer response to lower gas prices. The Numbers column reports that the typical consumer will spend about $600 less per year on gasoline with a $1 per gallon decrease in its price. "Spending less at the pump means having more money for other goods and services." With regard to automobile purchases in particular, consumers response very quickly to changes in gasoline prices in terms of the types of automobiles they purchase. With lower gasoline prices, consumers will rush back to larger, low-mileage vehicles.
QUESTIONS: 
1. (Advanced) What is the effect of a decrease in the price of gasoline on the value of imported goods and services in the U.S.?

2. (Advanced) What is the effect of a decrease in the price of gasoline on the size and fuel efficiency of automobiles purchased?

3. (Introductory) What are the possible effects of the decline in oil prices on the Texas economy?

Reviewed By: James Dearden, Lehigh University

A great example of derived demand

Good Times Run Out for Sand Producers
by: Dan Molinski
Jan 02, 2015
Click here to view the full article on WSJ.com

TOPICS: Oil Markets, Production, Supply and Demand
SUMMARY: Sand producers have enjoyed strong demand thanks to hydraulic fracturing, but analysts say not all of them are ready for the downturn that will come with the plunge in crude-oil prices. Related article: U.S. Steel said it will idle plants in Ohio and Texas and lay off 756 workers, becoming one of the first big U.S. industrial casualties of the recent collapse in global oil prices.
CLASSROOM APPLICATION: The article offers a case of a derived demand for an input into a production process. Students can use supply and demand for sand to evaluate the effect of a decrease in oil prices on the demand for sand. Students can also evaluate the labor and extraction rate decisions made by sand mining companies.
QUESTIONS: 
1. (Advanced) What is "derived demand"? Is the demand for sand derived from the demand for oil?

2. (Introductory) What is the effect of a decline on hydraulic fracturing on the equilibrium price of sand?

3. (Advanced) How are sand-mining companies responding to an anticipated decline in hydraulic fracturing?

Reviewed By: James Dearden, Lehigh University

Would community college be "free" under Obama's proposal

President Obama's recently proposed to make two years of community college free for students. He said, "What I'd like to do is to see the first two years of community college free for everybody who's willing to work for it."
  1. Is the opportunity cost zero for a student going to college if the government pays the tuition?

  2. Is the oppoirtunity cost for colleges providing the courses zero if the government pays the tuition?

  3. Is the opportunity cost of "work[ing] for it" zero?

  4. Is the opportunity cost of verifying that a student has a C+ average, that the student is making "steady progress", that "community colleges ... offer academic programs that fully transfer credits to local public four-year colleges and universities or training programs with high graduation rates that lead to in-demand degrees and certificates [and] ... adopt 'promising and evidence-based institutional reforms' to improve student outcomes' zero?

  5. Who pays any of the costs above if they are greater than zero?




Monday, December 15, 2014

Apple wanted a most favored nation clause

The WSJ reports that has appealed a decision that it fixed prices on ebooks. What caught my eye was a reference to a most favored nation clause.

SUMMARY: On Monday, an appeals court is scheduled to consider whether Apple's pricing agreements with e-book publishers amounted to a deft market maneuver or an illegal conspiracy. "Apple's agreements ceded the power to set prices to the [five major] publishers.... A key provision of the contracts required the publishers to give Apple's store the best deal that they gave anyone on e-books. That assured the publishers would force Amazon to change its business model, otherwise they would suffer heavy losses matching Amazon's discounted prices-$9.99 for most best sellers-in Apple's e-book store, prosecutors said. Prices on many e-books increased immediately." Related article: Justice Department lawyers faced aggressive questioning from judges reviewing a finding that Apple conspired with book publishers to raise the price of electronic books in 2010.
CLASSROOM APPLICATION: Students can evaluate whether "most-favored nation" clauses in contracts result in higher or lower prices. "So-called most favored-nation clauses are common in industries ranging from health care to television to financial services. Such clauses, like those in the Apple agreements, guarantee the recipient the lowest prices or rates charged to any buyer. In theory, such arrangements encourage competition and lower prices for consumers, but in practice they sometimes establish a minimum price, according to antitrust lawyers and government officials."
QUESTIONS: 
1. (Introductory) What are "most-favored nation" requirements? What are possible motivations by Apple to place most-favored national clauses in their contracts with book publishers?

2. (Advanced) What are the potential effects on competition among manufacturers of most-favored nation requirements between retailers and manufacturers?

3. (Advanced) What are the potential effects on retail prices of most-favored nation requirements between retailers and manufacturers?
Reviewed By: James Dearden, Lehigh University

Friday, December 12, 2014

Museums begin to engage visitors to capture and to mine data

The article in the WSJ reports that museums are starting to use tracking devices and digital social engagement to collect data for consumer research.